NFL commerce grades: Jalen Ramsey, Minkah Fitzpatrick, John Metchie III

The majority of the offseason could be over, however NFL groups nonetheless can mildew their rosters between now and Week 1. The easiest way to try this this time of 12 months? Trades. There are nonetheless weaknesses to shore up, gamers whom groups need to transfer on from and looming contracts to be settled.

And we bought an enormous transfer on the finish of June. The Dolphins traded cornerback Jalen Ramsey and tight finish Jonnu Smith to the Steelers for security Minkah Fitzpatrick and a late-round decide swap. Miami then traded for beforehand retired tight finish Darren Waller in a cope with the Giants. We weighed in on each trades, in addition to the 49ers’ commerce for Eagles edge rusher Bryce Huff from early June and Sunday’s swap between the Texans and Eagles involving WR John Metchie III, TE Harrison Bryant and draft picks that the franchises beforehand dealt to one another.

As all the time, I will be grading trades right here from every crew’s perspective. I will be wanting on the offers from all angles — together with high quality, age and contracts of the gamers dealt, wage cap implications, draft compensation and the short- and long-term outlooks of the groups concerned. I am going to additionally think about the impact of every deal and the way sure we may be that the transfer was optimistic or damaging. Let’s dive in.

Texans get: TE Harrison Bryant, 2026 fifth-round decide
Eagles get: WR John Metchie III, 2026 sixth-round decide

Eagles’ grade: B
Texans’ grade: B+

Probably the most fascinating a part of this commerce of depth items was that the Eagles and Texans each reacquired their very own unique picks from a commerce they made in March. The Texans regained the fifth-round decide they dealt to Philadelphia for C.J. Gardner-Johnson and the Eagles took again the sixth-rounder they traded for Kenyon Inexperienced.

It represents a traditional preseason deal by which Houston traded from a place of surplus to assist Philadelphia fill a necessity. Even with Tank Dell injured, the Texans have extra gamers at extensive receiver who might moderately make their 53-man roster. Nico Collins, Jayden Higgins, Christian Kirk, Justin Watson, Jaylin Noel, Xavier Hutchinson, Braxton Berrios have been all in that room, so the 2022 second-rounder may need been on the surface by way of making Houston’s roster.

Metchie, who missed what would have been his rookie season in 2022 after being recognized with leukemia, has made a restricted impression since his NFL debut in 2023. He has caught 40 passes for 412 yards and a paltry 1.1 yards per route run the previous two seasons. However the Eagles are fairly barren at extensive receiver after A.J. Brown and DeVonta Smith, so they have to determine it is value a shot to see whether or not they can extract Metchie’s potential. The bar is pretty low contemplating the Eagles’ receiver depth consists of gamers comparable to Jahan Dotson, Ainias Smith and Johnny Wilson.

On the opposite finish of this deal, Bryant — who has 98 profession receptions in 5 seasons however simply 9 in 2024 with the Raiders — was buried on the Eagles’ depth chart. He’ll be part of a bunch that options starter Dalton Schultz and depth gamers Cade Stover, Irv Smith Jr. and seventh-round decide Luke Lachey.

Each Schultz and Stover completed within the backside 10 in run block win fee amongst tight ends (and Schultz was final amongst TEs with at the very least 35 qualifying blocks in move block win fee), so Houston could be eyeing Bryant as a blocking improve. Bryant was roughly common in RBWR in 2023 and ranked fifth within the class in 2022 (he did not play sufficient to qualify final season).

Given the significance of the extensive receiver place, it is sensible for the Eagles to roll the cube on a long-shot participant who might assist. However this was a strong transfer for the Texans to get one thing for a participant whose roster spot wasn’t assured.

Dolphins get: TE Darren Waller, 2027 seventh-round decide
Giants get: 2026 conditional sixth-round decide

Dolphins’ grade: B+
Giants’ grade: B

For a second straight day, the Dolphins have made a shocking acquisition through commerce. This time it was Waller, the tight finish who retired a 12 months in the past with the Giants and didn’t play in 2024.

My easy takeaway right here: Why not?

After buying and selling Jonnu Smith to the Steelers, the Dolphins have been taking a look at an awfully barren tight finish room that includes Julian Hill and Pharaoh Brown. Each gamers mixed for 165 receiving yards and nil touchdowns final season (Brown was with the Seahawks and signed a one-year deal with the Dolphins in March). Whereas Miami absolutely hopes that Tyreek Hill and Jaylen Waddle obtain a better share of the targets this season, the crew wants a decent finish to be one other receiving choice for QB Tua Tagovailoa.

Waller, maybe, may very well be that. I would definitely mood any main expectations right here. Waller is 32 and has been out of the sport for a 12 months. The final time he recorded at the very least 700 receiving yards in a season was in 2020 with the Raiders. However he might simply be the perfect receiving tight finish the Dolphins have, and that is value one thing.

Miami additionally did not have to surrender a lot to get Waller. This was only a very late-round decide swap and a deal value as much as $5 million. So we’ll see what the actual cash finally ends up being, however it would doubtless be decrease than that. For the Giants, that is discovered cash beneath the sofa cushion. It is not a lot, however it’s higher than nothing.

Steelers get: CB Jalen Ramsey, TE Jonnu Smith, 2027 seventh-round decide
Dolphins get: S Minkah Fitzpatrick, 2027 fifth-round decide

Steelers’ grade: C
Dolphins’ grade: A

This was really a stunner.

Whereas it had been made abundantly clear that Ramsey was not going to be on the Dolphins in 2025, the truth that it was the Steelers buying and selling for him — there had lengthy been rumors Ramsey could be headed again to the Rams — was a shock. It was an entire shock that Fitzpatrick was the compensation in return. And Smith lumped in, too? Of us, this was a June blockbuster.

Let’s break this down from the extra advanced Steelers facet first. By signing quarterback Aaron Rodgers, the crew signaled it’s taking a long-shot swing at one other run whereas within the tail finish of the T.J. Watt/Cameron Heyward period. It had cash to spend — Pittsburgh has the third-most cap area in 2026. However including Ramsey and Smith in trade for Fitzpatrick remains to be jarring.

Ramsey, 30, is mostly thought of to be on the decline, although nearest defender numbers would considerably dispute that. Final season, Ramsey allowed 0.9 yards per protection snap, per NFL Subsequent Gen Stats, higher than the surface cornerback common of 1.1. He did that whereas principally enjoying an outdoor nook function (he aligned as a large CB 78% of the time). He additionally rushed the passer 36 instances with Miami final 12 months, essentially the most of any season in his profession.

Will probably be fascinating to see what Ramsey’s function is with Pittsburgh. With Joey Porter Jr. and Darius Slay Jr. (presumably?) put in as the surface corners, the crew can make use of Ramsey as a nickel and/or security — with the latter half seemingly notably possible given Fitzpatrick’s inclusion within the commerce. Ramsey performed important snaps as a slot nook when he was with the Rams and really often aligned as a security with the Jaguars early in his profession, per NFL Subsequent Gen Stats.

If Ramsey performed some type of hybrid nickel/security function, that might not be a like-for-like substitute of what the Steelers had Fitzpatrick do final season. Fitzpatrick performed deep security 80% of the time, and a variety of that was in middle discipline for the reason that Steelers performed two-high on the fourth-lowest fee within the league. At security, the Steelers now have DeShon Elliott and Juan Thornhill. Elliott performed extra of a field security/slot function final season however has performed extra deep security (coincidentally sufficient, with Miami) previously. And Thornhill performed a deep security function in 11 begins with Cleveland final season.

The monetary compensation issues right here. The Steelers are choosing up practically the whole lot of Ramsey’s tab — the majority of his $26.6 million in 2025 after giving him a light-weight increase. That is a reasonably hefty sum of money for him at this stage in his profession — and particularly if he is not enjoying outdoors cornerback. Previous to this commerce getting completed, I wasn’t even certain Miami was going to discover a crew prepared to select up the whole lot of Ramsey’s pre-raise contract. Sure, the Steelers have the cap room, however that they might tackle the contract must have helped them within the commerce negotiation; I do not know if I see the place it actually did. Ramsey is beneath non-guaranteed crew management for $21-24 million in money in every of 2026, 2027 and 2028, per OverTheCap.com.

Fitzpatrick, in the meantime, has two years left on his deal and can price Miami $15.5 million in 2025 and $17.6 million in 2026. These phrases in all probability supply the Dolphins good worth for Fitzpatrick, who made the Professional Bowl once more final season.

Smith appears to be an acquisition made with offensive coordinator Arthur Smith in thoughts. The pair labored collectively in Tennessee (the place Jonnu Smith had 137 YAC over expectation in 2019, per NFL Subsequent Gen Stats) and Atlanta. The addition doubtless means the Steelers will regularly play a number of tight ends without delay, with Smith alongside Pat Freiermuth and Darnell Washington.

However I am unable to assist however assume the Steelers are dealing for Smith at his absolute peak. Smith is coming off a profession 12 months by which he recorded 88 receptions for 884 yards with the Dolphins, however that does not imply we must neglect in regards to the seven years of relative mediocrity that got here earlier than it. Smith was underpaid on his previous contract, sure, however Pittsburgh is giving him a one-year extension for $12 million, which might wipe out that worth (although we do not know the construction but).

Altogether, I’ve a tough time getting on board with this transfer for the Steelers. It is logical for them to enhance the crew to maximise their upside. And there’s upside, notably as a result of the protection has the potential to be nice. However I do not know that this transfer actually improved Pittsburgh in 2025 or past, and it got here at a price. The optimistic view is that Ramsey has been a star previously and could be a star once more, and we would properly look again on this commerce as being a part of the belief of that upside case for Pittsburgh’s protection.

Let’s flip over to Miami’s facet right here, which is each extra simple and, from my perspective, a reasonably clear win.

The Dolphins had been searching for a taker on Ramsey. I assumed this might contain the Dolphins consuming a portion of Ramsey’s assured wage, however they ended up discovering a commerce associate that took on simply in regards to the full freight. Dropping Smith is not splendid, however the Dolphins’ offense is meant to funnel by way of Tyreek Hill and Jaylen Waddle, who every took a step again final season. If all goes as deliberate for Miami, much more targets ought to go to the 2 wideouts once more in 2025. And the identical evaluation on Smith holds right here, too: The Dolphins — who’re in a far tighter cap state of affairs — did not need to overpay the tight finish after a profession 12 months, and that is sensible.

After dropping Jevon Holland in free company, the Dolphins backfilled the security place with two new acquisitions: Ashtyn Davis (from the Jets) and Ifeatu Melifonwu (from the Lions), each on low-cost offers. In Fitzpatrick, they now have a longtime high-end security to switch Holland and get him at basically the identical numbers the Giants paid Holland (and with no ensures).

To prime all of it off, Miami will get a late-round draft decide swap in its favor on this deal. Miami wasn’t in a really perfect place, having one veteran it wanted to commerce and one other wanting a brand new contract the crew did not need to give. However by making this cope with the Steelers, the Dolphins bought essentially the most out of the hand that they had.

49ers get: Edge Bryce Huff
Eagles get: 2026 midround draft decide

49ers’ grade: B+
Eagles’ grade: B+

The 49ers are betting that Huff’s 2024 season was an outlier — not an indication of what is to come back.

A 12 months in the past, Huff was a high-end free agent who signed a three-year, $51.1 million deal with the Eagles after displaying critical pass-rushing chops with the Jets. Regardless of questions on his run protection, it appeared properly value it on the time. From 2020 to 2022, Huff recorded a 26% move rush win fee at edge — a top-10 quantity on the place had he certified — in a situational pass-rushing function. The sacks adopted when Huff bought extra enjoying time in 2023, with 10 that season earlier than hitting free company.

However Huff’s numbers instantly dropped in Philadelphia. His win fee fell to a career-low 19% (which remains to be greater than common), however the sacks weren’t there (2.5) and his enjoying time dipped earlier than he missed time within the second half of the season to have wrist surgical procedure. He was wholesome for the postseason however inactive for the Tremendous Bowl — a transparent signal of what Philadelphia considered his play.

play

Which crew is the most important risk to the Eagles within the NFC?

Louis Riddick explains why the Commanders pose the most important risk to the Eagles’ possibilities of repeating as NFC champions this season.

The 49ers have been searching for a high quality edge rusher reverse Nick Bosa. Their greatest funding in that space is first-round decide Mykel Williams, however Huff is one other swing.

This can be a fairly cheap play for San Francisco. As poorly as Huff performed final season, there’s nonetheless a lot to love in his historical past, and his move rush win fee remained strong regardless of his struggles. His move rush get-off (time to cross the road of scrimmage) has bounced round, from 0.8 seconds in 2021 to an absurd 0.67 in 2022 to 0.75 in 2023 and 0.79 in 2024.

Although that reveals Huff slowing down, it is nonetheless a better-than-average get-off for an edge rusher. The 49ers might put Huff again right into a situational pass-rushing function — with Williams dealing with run downs — which might in all probability swimsuit his ability set higher. And if there’s anybody who can get extra out of Huff, maybe it’s 49ers defensive coordinator Robert Saleh, who coached Huff with the Jets from 2021 to 2023.

Critically, the 49ers are usually not paying full value. As Area Yates laid out, the 49ers pays Huff slightly below $8 million this 12 months after he restructured his deal forward of this commerce. That, plus a Day 3 draft decide, looks like a worthwhile danger for a crew with Tremendous Bowl aspirations and a pass-rush want.

Alternatively, the Eagles clearly don’t really feel the identical about Huff. They’ve a bevy of options to play reverse Nolan Smith Jr., from veterans who’ve flashed previously (Azeez Ojulari and Joshua Uche) to a younger participant with promise (Jalyx Hunt). Philadelphia is not strolling away with an enormous haul, but when Huff was not a lock to be energetic on Sundays, then saving a couple of million and getting a draft decide is a reasonably good final result.